I-Appliance BBS
The Official Source for Internet Appliance Upgrades and Mods

Click Here!
BBS Main List | Sign In | Sign Up | Search | Help | Linux-Hacker.netReply to Thread | Printer |

Home / Other I-Appliances / Gateway/AOL Connected Touch Pad
Opinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener
Feel free to state your opinion and why!

New MessageOpinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener (modified 0 times) Epsilon1
Profile
Opinions, Which makes a better small computer? The GWCT or i-Opener? Which CPU actually performs better? Transmeta 400 or AMD K6 2+ 450 (Using Win 98/me and 128 MB ram)
05-17-2001 06:09:50

New MessageRE:Opinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener (modified 0 times) BigDog
Profile | Email
I ran an old version of Checkit 3.0 on a Pentium 200 w/t MMX and using the system performance save and compare, the CPU came up at about 167,000 drystones. When I ran it on the GTC (I was using the Pentium to load the hard drive), the system performance came up 1.3 times faster at about 226,000 drystones.

Tonight I will run on my v5 that has the Mp6-266 processor and see how it compares.

05-17-2001 08:02:29

New MessageRE:Opinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener (modified 0 times) info
Profile
Anyone else do any comparisons?
05-18-2001 05:32:34

New MessageRE:Opinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener (modified 0 times) yellow1
Profile | Email
The Transmeta SC3200 at 400mhz installed in the GWCP is most definitely not on par with a K2+ 450mhz installed in a desktop system. I once had a K6 at 300mhz PC and it would beat the pants off the GWCP.
Having said that, it's really not fair to compare a full blown desktop system with an appliance that was built cutting corners to make it as cheap as possible. I'm not too familiar with the iOpener's upgrade path, but if you've put a K6 2+ in there, you might be faced with the same constraints as on the Touchpad, i.e. limited RAM, limited Video memory, etc...The SC3200 also seems to be bogged down by its memory hungry code-morphing approach coupled with its lack of L2 cache.
I've had the GWCP up for two weeks and it's adequate to stream mp3s, play real audio/video streams and light web browsing (I would recommend the new 16bit Terminal Services clients, if you want to do a lot of web browsing). It slows down a lot when multitasking but to its credit it runs solid, unlike my webplayer that crashed pretty regularly.
05-18-2001 08:51:18

New MessageRE:Opinions, Which makes a better small computer : The GCT or i-Opener (modified 0 times) ckbone
Profile
Look....it's hard to compare these two computers because each has it's strong points. In the case of the I-Opener it's the ability to easily upgrade the cpu. I'll list the Sandra benchmarks for an I-Opener running a Kingston Turbochip 400 (a drop-in upgrade requiring no soldering), on Win98se with 128meg ram.

CPU benchmarks: 748ALU..492FPU
CPU Multimedia benchmarks: Integermmx1312...Floating point 3DNow 1716
Memory Benchmarks: ALU/Ram49...FPU/Ram...64

Running these benchmarks with an ORB USB drive connected did not affect the scores. From what I can tell, the Transmeta 400, does not really compare to an AMD400 or a PentiumII400. Of course you can argue these scores do not translate into real-world usage. Perhaps not, but higher scores equal a faster computer, all other things being the same. And they are here with these two computers...maximum ram, video performance, screen, etc. Even the cost overall of the separate hacks is pretty close. What I'm saying here is, I'm sticking with what I have, unless I can find a better deal on a GCT. FWIW...those people who have hacked the I-Opener severly (soldering on the board) have reported much higher scores using an AMDK62-450+, probably 20% higher.

05-18-2001 19:11:16

Reply to Thread | Printer |
All times are PSTPowered by UltraBoard v1.62



Copyright © 2000, Netmake Inc. All Rights Reserved.
See Terms and Conditions for more information.




i-opener opener laptop notebook computer help drivers dll free windows dos repair fix linux mac macintosh 2000 95 98 nt pc configure hardware software sound video netscape explorer network networking lan wan software cmos fat bios printer card mouse modem ide scsi cd rom controllers scanner tape hard drive cgi scripts source code mp3