I-Appliance BBS
The Official Source for Internet Appliance Upgrades and Mods
Amazon Honor System Click Here to Pay Learn More
BBS Main List | Sign In | Sign Up | Search | Help | Linux-Hacker.netReply to Thread | Printer |

Home / Other I-Appliances / Virgin Webplayer
What's the best Linux distro to use?

New MessageWhat's the best Linux distro to use? (modified 0 times) tomkarlo
Profile
Okay, so I have a WebPlayer, Toshiba 3 GB, 9.5mm drive, drive cable and Linksys WUSB11 on the way to me. What's the best Linux distribution to use on it? Is it an intel (i386,i586,i686) architecture? Given that people are running Windows on it, I assume it is.

Also, has anyone tried using a bootable USB flash drive instead of an HD or DOC? I have a 32MB one that can be booted as a USB FDD or HDD, it's not big enough but larger versions are out there.

I'm primarily familiar with Mandrake but I'm willing to try any other distro. I looked at Midori but I think it's overkill to use that since I'm adding the hard drive.

So what should I use? Debian, Suse, RH, Mandrake? All I want to run on it is a nice windowing system and Mozilla - I'm building an email/terminal for my mother, so I can finally get her off Hotmail. Plus, I think it's a great experiment in seeing how non-computer-savvy folks do using Linux (I think it won't make any difference to her, aside from being really cheap, fast and stable.)

05-21-2002 17:04:26

New MessageRE:What's the best Linux distro to use? (modified 0 times) mbcook
Profile
You should realize that asking a question like this is dangerous. Distro wars errupt VERY quickly. That said, here is what I can tell you. If you're new to linux, Mandrake is a great distro. Personally though, I like Debian (specifically Woody). It's harder to set up, but I find it to be a much better disrobution. Also, once you've used apt-get or anything related to the deb packages, you'll NEVER want to go back to RPM based distros as long as you live. Or at least, that's my expirence. There is nothing like having your system running and deciding that you want to install the GIMP. With an RPM system, you go and find it. Then you try to install. They you get the missing dependencies and install them first. But first you must get the dependencies for the dependencies, etc. With Debian you just type "apt-get install gimp". Need dependencies? Debian does it for you. Want to make sure your packages are always the newest? Just "apt-get upgrade", you don't have to manualy find out what out of date. It's vastly superior. But again, this is all IMHO.
05-23-2002 14:40:19

New MessageRE:What's the best Linux distro to use? (modified 0 times) tomkarlo
Profile
Didn't mean to start a fight :) I'm experienced with several distros but I'm purely agnostic about operating systems in general. Whatever does the job.

I asked this question because the webplayer has special needs vs. a standard desktop. I spent a lot of time this week investigating "minimal" linux distros but none seem appropriate. Going back to "heavy" distros I narrowed it down to this list of choices:

1. Mandrake - I'm most familiar with this.
2. Debian - Yes, RPM dependencies piss me off (but I won't do many installs)
3. Gentoo - Relatively light but non-trivial to install for me.
4. Beehive - very tight distro (500 MB) but targeted at sysadmins.
5. Lycoris (great for small desktops but might not handle non-standard hardware. Wouldn't install on my Dell laptop at all.)

Distrowatch (.0rg?) was tremendously helpful in letting me do research.

I'm using a 3 GB Hitachi HD so I'm going to try Mandrake and see if I can't trim the system down enough that it's snappy. I guess I'll use Gnome 1.4 as the wm. Any suggestions for making it faster would be deeply appreciated.

I'm going to make my first attempt using the 3GB Mandrake drive that I made to use on my laptop while playing around with distros. Not sure what will happen when I pop it in the webplayer and reboot.

Eventually I'll attempt to put linux on DOC on my second webplayer.

05-30-2002 11:12:10

Reply to Thread | Printer |
All times are PSTPowered by UltraBoard v1.62



Copyright © 2000, Netmake Inc. All Rights Reserved.
See Terms and Conditions for more information.




i-opener opener laptop notebook computer help drivers dll free windows dos repair fix linux mac macintosh 2000 95 98 nt pc configure hardware software sound video netscape explorer network networking lan wan software cmos fat bios printer card mouse modem ide scsi cd rom controllers scanner tape hard drive cgi scripts source code mp3